Lawrence Solum對於原意主義的數篇討論(Lawrence Solum’s Posts on Originalism)

在四月初,Lawrence Solum在自己部落格中開始發表對於原意主義相關辯論以及問題的想法,他有意識地將為原意主義解釋方法論所涉及到的相關問題的結構表現出來!我將在本篇中一一轉載。這幾篇都非常值得一看!!我想,Solum教授已經逐漸形成一套他為原意主義鋪下的基本道路。在某個意義上,這個道路是隨著Neil Gorsuch的提名與任命而加速發展!

  1. The Case for Originalism, Part One: Framing the Debate
  2. The Case for Originalism, Part Two: Methods of Justification
  3. The Case for Originalism, Part Three: The Baseline Comparison of Originalism with Constitutional Eclecticism
  4. The Case for Originalism, Part Four: The Fixation Thesis
  5. The Case for Originalism, Part Five: The Argument for Originalism from the Rule of Law
  6. The Case for Originalism, Part Six: The Argument for Originalism from Legitmacy
  7. The Case for Originalism, Part Seven: Underdeterminacy and the Construction Zone

如果Solum教授有持續發表,我將在這一篇文章章持續更新。我自己的感覺是,隨著Gorsuch的任命,接下來無疑地仍就有數場憲法解釋的辯論等著出現。這幾篇可看性都很高,強烈推薦給大家,特別是從第五篇開始將解釋方法與憲政法理學結合。

Advertisements


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s